Mariah Carey’s VMAs performance at the 2025 MTV Video Music Awards drew both praise and criticism. The pop icon performed a medley of her greatest hits while receiving the prestigious Video Vanguard Award, and fans took to social media to share their mixed reactions.
Performance Highlights
Carey performed classics including Sugar Sweet, Fantasy, Heartbreaker, and We Belong Together at the UBS Arena in Elmont, New York. Her medley coincided with her receipt of the Video Vanguard Award, which celebrates artists who have profoundly impacted music video and pop culture. Ariana Grande introduced Carey, calling her “the soundtrack of our lives,” adding to the celebratory atmosphere.
However, many viewers on X (formerly Twitter) noticed a difference in the performance’s energy. Comments ranged from observations about minimal movement to claims of lip-syncing. One fan remarked, “Mariah Carey on that stage giving us absolutely nothing,” while another wrote, “Am I crazy or does it seem like Mariah Carey is lip-syncing and also stiff as a board?”
Celebrating a Legendary Career
Despite mixed reviews, Carey’s achievement remains historic. This marked her first VMA win, adding to her decades-long influence in music. Carey reflected on the milestone at the podium:
“Thank you so much MTV for giving me the Vanguard Award. I can’t believe I’m getting my first VMA tonight. I just have one question: What in the Sam Hill were you waiting for?! I’m kidding, I love you, MTV … This is amazing.”
She also reminisced about past experiences with the award show, including presenting LL Cool J his Vanguard Award and opening the show alongside Whitney Houston, highlighting her long-standing legacy in pop music.
Social Media Reactions
While Carey’s fans praised her iconic status and vocal talent, many online users criticized the performance’s stage presence and perceived lip-syncing. Nonetheless, her recognition as a Video Vanguard solidifies her role as one of music’s most influential figures.
Mariah Carey’s VMAs appearance was a blend of celebration and controversy. The star delivered a memorable medley while earning the Video Vanguard Award, yet social media reactions reveal the high expectations audiences have for legendary performers. Regardless of the critiques, Carey’s impact on music and pop culture remains undeniable, proving why she continues to hold a revered place in entertainment history.
